In this dialogue
Was medieval sword fighting really just brute force?
In films, it often looks like two people going at each other with big swords until the stronger one wins. What would you show me to help me understand what was really going on?
I’d show you a book. It’s called I.33, and it dates from the early 14th century. It uses pictures and text to explain a system of fencing with a one-handed sword and a small shield called a buckler. The text is mostly in Latin, with some German fencing terms. Fight books vary quite a bit. Some illustrate the sequences, some have only a few pictures, and some rely entirely on text. Royal Armouries · University of Helsinki · Catalogue of Illustrated German Manuscripts
Fencing groups are still working out exactly what some of those sequences mean. That’s where historical fencing starts for me. We read the sources, look at the pictures where we have them, and test our interpretations in training.
Why does it look so different on screen?
So where did I get that picture in my head?
If you’ve never fenced, most of the sword fights you’ve seen were probably in films. And a screen fight has a job to do. You need to see who has the upper hand, who you’re rooting for, and when the danger rises. When I choreograph a fight for the camera, I shape the movement around what the audience needs to understand in that moment.
In historical fencing, I ask what problem the movement was meant to solve for the fencer. Form follows function. How spectacular a movement looks tells you very little about what it does.
Doesn’t the stronger person have the advantage?
If someone is bigger, stronger and can keep going longer, surely that gives them an edge?
Strength and athleticism help. But size alone tells you very little about how well someone fences. Many surviving swords are lighter and better balanced than you might expect from watching films. When I watch two people fence in training, I look at how much control they have, how they manage distance, and how they respond to each other. That’s where experience shows. The Metropolitan Museum of Art
How do I get started?
Can I teach myself to fence from a book like that?
Take a look at I.33. Even without reading Latin, you can see from the illustrations that someone set out to record fencing step by step. A translation can help you understand what the text says about a movement. Working out what that means in practice is part of what we do in historical fencing. Explore I.33 at the Royal Armouries
If you want to give fencing a go yourself, come along to a training session. We’ll start by looking at which training sword suits you, how to handle it, and how to move with it. The more complex sequences come later. If you’ve already bought a sword, start here. I bought a sword. Where do I start?