In this dialogue
Same weapon, same way of fencing?
I understand now that medieval fencing could be taught as a system. Did a fencer in Italy and one in the German-speaking lands learn much the same thing?
They faced similar problems and had different systems for dealing with them. Take the longsword. Two edges, a point and a crossguard. The physics works the same way in Bologna as it does in Nuremberg. Both fencers have to think about distance, angles and keeping themselves covered. What interests me is what each teacher explains first and what they emphasise in the fencing itself.
How can I tell the difference?
What would I notice if I looked at Liechtenauer and Fiore?
With Johannes Liechtenauer, I’d start by asking who has the initiative. Who is setting the pace of the exchange? Who has to respond? In the sources you’ll come across terms like Vor, Nach and Indes. For a first look, all I’d ask you to notice is that the initiative can change hands within a single exchange. An early version of Liechtenauer’s teaching survives in the Nuremberg manuscript Hs. 3227a. Handschriftencensus · Hs. 3227a with English translation
With Fiore dei Liberi, I’d start by showing you one of his poste, or named starting positions. In his Fior di Battaglia, the illustrations let you follow how he moves from those positions into different situations. What stands out to me is how naturally sword fencing and close-range wrestling sit within the same system. The Getty manuscript is dated to around 1410. Getty Museum · Text and image comparison of the Fiore manuscripts
What about England and Spain?
Can we say the same about other countries?
The first thing I’d ask is when the source was written. In his Paradoxes of Defence, published in 1599, the Englishman George Silver explains why he favoured shorter weapons over the long rapier. In Spain, Jerónimo de Carranza published his work on fencing in 1582. Geometry plays an important role in the Verdadera Destreza tradition. The two authors show how differently fencing teachers could explain their art. Both were writing well after Fiore. British Library · Biblioteca Virtual de Andalucía · Research on early modern fencing
Do I have to pick a tradition when I start?
What does all this mean for me if I’m just getting started?
The first time you watch a training session, ask: “Which source are you working from today, and what should I look for?” The answer will tell you what the group pays attention to. That session might focus on initiative or on starting positions. As you get to know other sources and weapons, you’ll start recognising familiar ideas. To me, it’s the same language of mechanics, spoken with different accents. That variety is what makes it interesting to me.