In this dialogue
Grip tightly or stay loose?
Henrik, when I grip the stick tightly, my whole arm goes stiff. When I loosen up, I'm afraid it'll fly out of my hand. How tightly should I hold it?
You've described the problem pretty well already. Squeeze the stick with all your strength all the time, and sooner or later your forearm seizes up. You become stiff and can barely make quick changes of direction.
You often see the opposite extreme in fancy stick twirling. Some people hold the stick with only three fingers, while the ring finger and little finger hang fairly loosely in the air. That gives the wrist lovely freedom of movement. But when the stick hits another stick or meets resistance, it can fly out of your hand.
A useful grip lies between those extremes. All your fingers wrap around the stick, while your wrist stays mobile. I know: “somewhere in between” is exactly what a beginner doesn't want to hear. That's why I have you try it for yourself.
How do I get a feel for it?
Which exercise will help me?
If you have access to a suitable heavy bag, take the stick in your right hand if you're right-handed. You need a target designed to withstand stick strikes, something you won't immediately destroy.
Now make an X-cut: from high on your right to low on your left, then straight away from high on your left to low on your right. The two lines form an X. Start slowly and with little force. Keep enough distance from other people and make sure there's clear space for the stick.
This teaches your hand its first important lesson: how firmly do I need to hold the stick so it stays secure on impact? And how much do I need to relax again so my wrist stays mobile for the next strike? Practice gives you that feedback.
Do I squeeze briefly on impact?
Do I keep the same grip pressure throughout, or squeeze a little harder on impact?
That's already quite an advanced question. Your body eventually develops that timing intuitively. But you can pay attention to it from the start: during acceleration, hold the stick relatively loosely, with all your fingers closed around it. Briefly squeeze harder on impact. Then release the extra tension again. Don't squeeze so hard that you become completely rigid.
You may recognise something similar from karate: the movement starts loosely from the hips, the arm accelerates and tension builds briefly at the moment of impact. It's a bit like a whip crack: start soft and relaxed, then become effective at the decisive moment. That's a comparison for the timing, not an instruction to lock your arm straight on impact.
How do I know I'm gripping too tightly?
What are the first signs that I'm tensing up again?
Your hand feels heavy after a short time. Your forearm gets tired, perhaps it starts shaking, and you want to put the stick down and shake your hand out. If something hurts, stop the exercise.
Look at how quickly strikes change direction in many styles of Eskrima, Arnis and Kali. It's less like one big swing with a baseball bat. You want to connect small, fast strikes as smoothly as possible. A stiff wrist makes that hard work. Then your shoulder and forearm do more and more, and you tire even faster.
Check your X-cut: does the second strike flow from the first, or do you have to reset your whole arm each time? Slow down again and let go of unnecessary tension between impacts.
If you're still looking for a stick: Which stick do I need to start? Next, we look at the free hand.